Kim G C Moody’s Musings – 1-1-1 Newsletter For November 18, 2026
One Comment About Taxation – A Tax System Shouldn’t Have Captains
Throughout my life, I have been “vertically challenged” – code for short. In grade school, I was a speedy skater with good hands and thus a good hockey player. I was often the captain of my minor hockey teams. But in any sport that rewarded height, like basketball, I was not great. When teams were chosen, I was generally the last one picked.
Same kid, same effort. Whether I went first or last depended entirely on which game was being played.
That’s how tax policy increasingly works. Governments choose the game, then choose the team. Everyone else waits against the gym wall.
Budget 2026 is the latest example. It promises to make “up to $45,000 of artistic earnings tax free” through a new Canada Creative Credit. Prime Minister Mark Carney has been actively promoting it on social media. The fine print is less generous. The budget only promises consultation. The credit would be non-refundable, the $45,000 includes the $16,452 basic personal amount everyone already gets, and only net business income from “original and creative artistic works” qualifies. If, like most federal credits, it’s calculated at the lowest rate of 14 per cent, it would be worth about $4,000 a year.
Consider two self-employed Canadians who each net $55,000. One paints landscapes. The other is an electrician. Both run small businesses, and both spent years mastering a craft. Under this proposal, the painter could pay about $4,000 less federal tax than the electrician on identical income. Why? How is this fair? The budget doesn’t say.
Tax economists call the principle being broken horizontal equity. Not to be confused with my vertical challenge, it simply means people in similar economic circumstances should pay similar tax. Its cousin, vertical equity – how much more higher earners should pay – is a separate debate. Ignore horizontal equity and you get unfairness, but also distortion: when the tax system favours one kind of income, people find ways to dress their income up to fit, and governments write more rules to stop them. Could my tax advice be characterized as original and creative work, making me a taxation artist?
Populist tax carve-outs are as old as taxes themselves. Canada’s ridiculous two-month GST holiday over Christmas 2024 was one. The latest U.S. version, the One Big Beautiful Bill Act, lets certain workers deduct up to US$25,000 of tips from 2025 through 2028, phasing out above US$150,000 of income. Only tips earned in occupations on a government list qualify. Treasury’s final regulations, published in April, refused to let other jobs onto the list and tightened the rules against relabelling other pay as tips. The final list even added visual artists. The companion “no tax on overtime” deduction, worth up to US$12,500 a year, excludes salaried executive, administrative and professional employees.
Other countries have picked their own teams and also play the populist game.
Ireland has exempted artists’ income since 1969, now up to €50,000 a year, but only for works the tax authority decides are “original and creative” and have “cultural or artistic merit.” Tax officials as art critics. Appeals keep coming; a recent one asked whether street art counts as a “painting.”
Hungary exempted mothers of three from income tax for life, then mothers of two under 40. When a new government took power this year, it didn’t scrap the exemption. Its first budget proposes to keep it, capped at a gross monthly income of one million forints, and to cancel the promised extension to older mothers. Once a team is picked, nobody gets cut.
Greece has picked by age. Since January, workers up to age 25 pay no income tax on up to €20,000, and those aged 26 to 30 pay nine per cent instead of 20 per cent on income between €10,000 and €20,000. Portugal goes further. Workers up to 35 can get up to 10 years of partial exemption, capped at €28,737.50 in 2025. A 36-year-old earning the same salary is out of luck.
Back home, professionals are the kids always picked last. The 2018 expansion of the tax on split income and the passive investment income rules were aimed squarely at them and other small business owners. Now look at Budget 2026’s headline measure, the Canada Growth Incentive, a $15-million capital gains exemption for founders. Most of the economy is cut from the roster: professional practices, consulting, farming, fishing, forestry, mining, finance, insurance, real estate, restaurants and hotels and, ironically, arts and entertainment. Manufacturers, life sciences firms and technology companies make the team. Artists, it seems, start one game and ride the bench in the next.
Every carve-out or exemption adds complexity: definitions, eligibility tests, anti-avoidance rules and audits. That cuts against Budget 2026’s simplification principles, which promise tax rules “easier to understand, comply with, and benefit from” and fewer “unnecessary interactions” with the CRA. You can’t simplify a rulebook while writing a new exception for every team.
None of this is free. Every carve-out narrows the tax base, and the budget doesn’t put a cost on the Creative Credit. The lost revenue shows up as higher rates on your paycheque or more debt for the next generation. If you aren’t picked, you help pay for those who are.
If the government believes the first $45,000 of a struggling painter’s income should be tax-free, why not for a struggling plumber, server or bookkeeper? There’s a better option: broad-based relief. Lower rates for everyone, or one generous credit that replaces the patchwork of targeted ones. The painter and the electrician would keep the same amount of the same dollar, and nobody would need to prove their art has merit to a tax official.
On the ice, I was picked first because I could skate. On the court, I was picked last because I couldn’t reach the rim. Kids can be forgiven for choosing teams that way.
Governments can’t. A tax system shouldn’t have captains. It should have one set of rules, and everyone gets to play.
One Comment About Leadership – The Exception Is the Rule
Every organization has a written set of rules and a real one. The real one is whatever your best performer gets away with.
Most leaders know the pattern. The top salesperson skips the meetings everyone else must attend. The brilliant partner is rude to junior team members and nobody says a word. Each exception looks sensible at the time because the results are too good to risk. Believe me, I’ve been guilty of this early in my career and gave high performers a pass. I thought I was doing the right thing.
But the people you lead don’t read the policy manual. They watch what you tolerate. Once they see that the standard depends on who you are, the good ones stop believing you and the rest stop trying.
Three habits help:
- Apply the standard to your star first.
- Grant an exception only if you’d explain it to the whole room – and the explanation had better be more than “the star deserves a pass”.
- Reward results with pay, never with immunity.
A standard that bends for your favourites isn’t a standard. It’s a privilege. And privilege, once tolerated, becomes culture. Leaders, remember that the exceptions you permit today become the standards your people follow tomorrow.
One Comment About Economics / Politics – The Stellantis Mess: What It Costs and What Ottawa Should Do Next
The news, briefly. On November 9, 2026, Stellantis said it is selling its idled Brampton, Ontario assembly plant to an armoured-vehicle maker. Ottawa committed up to $529 million in 2022 to retool the company’s Brampton and Windsor plants, and records show $222 million was paid out by March 2025. The government has now served Stellantis with a notice of default and threatened to sue, while it and Ontario have put an “aggressive package” on the table to stop the sale. Stellantis has offered $24 million back.
I’ve written about this before. In February 2024, in the Financial Post, I pointed out that Ottawa had quietly made the battery production subsidies promised to Volkswagen and to the Stellantis-LG joint venture tax-free. It did so by regulation, with no bill and no debate in Parliament. That was a separate deal from the Brampton and Windsor retooling money now in dispute. I called it a fairy tale for select corporations. Here is how it’s going: Stellantis agreed this past February to sell its share of that battery plant to its partner for US$100, and now it is leaving Brampton.
Why this matters beyond Brampton:
- Taxpayers are exposed twice: at least $222 million is already out the door with $24 million offered back, and now there is a new package on top.
- Every other subsidized company is watching. The Parliamentary Budget Officer costed government support for just three battery plants at $43.6 billion. If a broken commitment earns a sweeter offer, they will all take note.
- Every unsubsidized employer is watching too. They pay full freight, and they are learning that lobbying pays better than building.
- Investors see a country where the terms depend on who you are.
The usual defence is that other countries pay, so Canada must. Stellantis took the money and moved the Jeep to Illinois anyway.
What should happen next:
- Pull the new package. You don’t offer more to a party you have just put on notice of default.
- Enforce the contract. Collect what is owed, in court if necessary.
- Publish the agreements. MPs have seen the 2022 contract. Ottawa still has not published it.
- Pause new company-specific deals until an independent body reports what the existing ones cost and delivered.
- Put the money into conditions every employer can use: lower business tax rates and faster approvals.
- No more tax rules written for individual deals. If a subsidy is to be tax-free, put it in a bill and let Parliament debate it.
Canada can’t buy loyalty from a multinational. It can be a country worth staying in.
Bonus Comment – From George Orwell – English Novelist – About Equality
“All animals are equal, but some animals are more equal than others.”
Agree. Orwell wrote that in Animal Farm in 1945 as satire. Too many organizations, and governments, run it as policy.
I hope today’s newsletter has been thought-provoking for you.
As many of you know, I’m passionate about helping people make better decisions – whether in tax, leadership, or business. If you’d like to go deeper on those topics, my recently released book, Making Life Less Taxing Version Two is now available and expands on many of the practical ideas I’ve written about over the years.
I’m also putting the finishing touches on my next book, Leadership Compounds: How Small Decisions Build Culture, Credibility, and Legacy. It explores a simple but powerful idea: leadership isn’t about grand gestures – it’s about the small, consistent decisions that compound over time.
For those interested in a more hands-on approach, I’ll soon be announcing a bespoke consulting initiative – The Acorn Growth Program – designed to help leaders and organizations grow intentionally, one small (but important) decision at a time. Feel free to reach out to me directly for more information.
And if you’re not already on my mailing list, feel free to sign up for my In the Mood Network newsletters to receive more content. No fluff – just practical insights on tax, leadership, and economic policy.
Thanks for reading. As always, I welcome your thoughts and feedback.
Amazon Books
Apple Books
